My 4 Favorite Pumps (and why you’ll want them all!)

What’s YOUR favorite pump? Why do you love it?
* TELL US IN THE COMMENTS, PLEASE! We want to know! *

Every momma’s body responds differently to different breast pumps, so if you can, it’s best to try out more than one type/style of pump. We all have different lifestyles as well, and that means one style of pump might work better than another, and having a variety of pumps means you are better supported for the variation in your own life.
Here are the 4 breast pumps I used the most during nearly two years of exclusive pumping. (yes I used more pumps than this, lol)

First, let’s talk some basics about different kinds of breast pumps. You might have heard the terms “Hospital Grade” or “Primary/Secondary” to describe types of pumps. These are often pretty confusing terms, especially when they are thrown around as much as they are.

What does “Hospital Grade” even mean?

If you’ve used a breast pump in a hospital, it’s most likely been the Medela Symphony or the Ameda Platinum. These are highly expensive pumps designed to withstand multiple users. While some are rentable, mommas usually don’t purchase them for home use. When companies (like Spectra or Pumpables) use this term for marketing, they are saying that the pump has a stronger, more durable motor for frequent use, like exclusive pumping. These pumps are often also “closed system” which means that a barrier exists so milk does not get inside the pump, which means it’s okay for multiple users.

What about “Primary/Secondary” pumps?

A primary pump should be a strong, durable pump that your body responds well to (empties you fully and efficiently, helping to build and protect your supply.) If you are exclusively pumping, meaning using a pump up to 8+ times a day instead of nursing) you’ll want a good primary pump. A secondary pump usually has a weaker motor, and your body might not respond as well to it, so it might not empty you as well. Secondary pumps should be used less frequently, especially for exclusive pumpers.

I bet you’re looking for brand names for primary and secondary pumps, right? The thing is… what works well for one momma may not work as well for another. Here’s an example: Generally, a pump like Spectra S1/2 would be a primary pump, whereas a wearable like Elvie or MomCozy would be a secondary pump. However, I’ve known mommas to not respond to a Spectra, however, and only use an Elvie. Some mommas only use manual pumps instead of electric, and I’ve even known a few to prefer hand-expressing to any kind of pump at all!

Okay Melissa, but what are YOUR favorite pumps? Here’s my list:
*Ranked in order of how often I used them*

1) Electric Pump (Spectra)

Ah my trusty double-electric pump. (“Double” just means you can pump both breasts at once.) As an exclusive pumper, it was essential to have a quality pump that my body responded well to. Got a used one to keep at work, too. Spectra S1 was my pump of choice but Motif makes a similar one and many brands are stepping up the quality of their electric pumps, so read reviews!

Pros of a double electric pump:

• They are usually “hospital grade” in stregth, withstanding heavy use
• They are usually closed-system so they can be safe for second-hand use
• They are usually available through insurance
• Their parts are usually easier to find, even at stores like Target
• Amazon carries generic versions of their accessories so you can find your ideal flange size that might not be available from the manufacturer

Cons of a double electric pump

• They can be expensive, out of pocket
• Many are physically larger or heavier
• Some models need to remain plugged into a wall
• It can be more difficult to multitask

2) Manual Pump (Medela)

Total game changer for me- I threw it in my diaper bag and pumped everywhere! SO quick and easy with minimal clean-up. I no longer felt the need to rush home to pump. I pumped a lot in the car, and also used it to relieve clogs. I used the Medela Harmony but Lansinoh has a decent one, too

Proc of a manual pump:

• Super affordable
• Small and lightweight
• Can be quicker if you get good at it
• You control the speed and suction
• Great to use for “mini sessions” or to relieve yourself
• Can be off-centered to relieve clogged ducts!

Cons of a manual pump:

• Can only pump one breast at a time
• Hard on the hands, if used frequently
• There’s a bit of a learning curve, so watch demo videos!

3) Portable Pump (Baby Buddha)

I am a major multitasking momma so having a portable pump REALLY helped around the house. I’ve done just about everything while pumping! I used the Baby Buddha with my Spectra and Lacteck accessories- when you know what you like, stick with it- most pumps are hack-able. The Pumpables Genie Advanced is a great portable option, too.

Pros of a portable pump

• So much freedom to multitask!
• Lightweight, can be worn via lanyard or clip
• Usually more affordable

Cons of a portable pump

• Many would be considered “secondary pumps” for infrequent use
• More difficult to find replacement parts
• Often smaller variety of flange sizes

4) Wearable Pump (Elvie)

Honestly this was my biggest splurge and not really worth it by the time I got it. YES I was able to pump in restaurants, while shopping, at the movies, etc…. but not everyone needs to be that discrete. If you want a nearly silent pump, spring for the Elvie… if you just want a wearable, MomCozy makes great, more affordable options that are a tad louder. 

Pros of a wearable pump:

• Super discrete
• Can often pump unnoticed in public
• Very easy to multitask while pumping

Cons of a wearable pump

• More quiet versions are pricey
• Adds volume to bustline
• Tends to empty less fully
• Should be reserved for a secondary pump
• Not great for mommas with oversupply, as bottles hold 4-6 ounces each